Spazsdad wrote:"infield rocket hit "....."looked like she was going to beat it out"
Usually hard hit balls are the ones you can't beat out since the fielder received the ball so quickly.
Tough one but you can't assume what might have happened. Bottom line the throw was bad and 1B didn't field it.
I would score that as reached on error
I don't agree. If the throw would NOT have resulted in an out, it is a hit.
Example: Slapper bounces one to short, F6 kicks the ball with baserunner two feet from 1st base. Base hit.
You don't want to get to a point where the offensive player is rooting for the defense to make the damn play so they can have their hit.
However, in the example above, I don't see how the runner was going to beat it if it was a "rocket" to third. Doesn't add up.