by ajaywill » Wed Aug 10, 2011 12:06 pm
Nope.
Not only is it not a good call, but the umpire's explanation has now made it a protestable call.
There is no requirement in the rules for a runner to slide in this situation. If the umpire is saying there is, then s/he is not interpreting the rule correctly and the call is subject to protest.
Disclaimer: above answer based solely on description of play presented, without having seen the play or hearing the umpires version of the play.