by dittoz » Wed Jan 27, 2010 7:47 am
Don't be surprised if the only big fans of a particular instructor are those who go to him/her. Those who go elsewhere will be fans of someone else.
Like shoes, it's pretty likely that the best fit is an individual experience and while opinions are like hair (most people have them), what is good for one is not always good for another.
There are a great many very good and very experienced hitting instructors in Northern California and it really depends on who the student is and how much work they're willing to put in. I've seen instructors who are phenominal in my opinion yet a student has utterly failed after going to them for an extended period of time because they refuse to practice beyond team and instructor sessions. On the other hand, I've seen very marginal instructors claim success because the student they work with simply lacked any formalized plan until they started seeing someone. Once they started on a course of action they worked hard and became a success because of their own hard work.
Lastly, different hitters are best with different styles. I cringe when I see a hitting instructor immediately try to force a hitter into this cookie-cutter style. You must rotate, you must go linear, you must do this... you must do that... Every hitter employs some of the same basic fundamentals, but not every hitter gets there in the same manner and not every hitter has the same success with the same style. My own daughter is a good example of this concept. She is 14 and stands 5' 1. On rainy days when she walks home, she weighs maybe 85 pounds. She is not the picture of a power hitter and does not do well when employing pure conventional "rotational" mechanics. She learned them early on and hit the ball consistently, but never had the power that she does now using the method that some refer to as linear-to-rotational. Prior to her current hitting coach, the last few she had tried to make her stay back, never move forward into the ball and even went so far as to try tying her to the fence to keep her back in practice. Her current coach took a different track and refined the forward movement and she immediately hit the ball harder than she ever had before. This same coach works with several other girls and is on the 18G staff at AASA. Some of the girls are power hitters and stay back, others are more linear.
So bottom line, the best hitting coach is the one that has the best success with the most girls.
In my opinon...
(YRMV)
Last edited by
dittoz on Wed Jan 27, 2010 12:03 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Being from NorCal, what do I know anyway???