jbl1465 wrote:I agree there are not a lot of good coaches for sure. I watch these games with coaches yelling at kids mid play or mid at bat thinking they are doing good. I would love for them to go to a college game and just watch the coaches. You never hear a negative comment. Now having said that I don't think the athletes are out there either. I watched TC try outs and you could have sent over half those kids home during warm ups. They couldn't play catch. "A" travel ball is not where you come to learn the basics, rec and the field down the street with your mom or dad is where those skills are perfected. But like the housing market (getting a ton of mileage out of that analogy) it is a free market and if the Dirtdogs can find 12 families willing to shell out a ton of cash to play ball power to them. I hope they prove me wrong and field a team that goes deep into every Sunday.
I've seen far too many kids that have good speed, strong arms, or some other very good attribute that isn't developed to believe the talent level is completely watered down. The coaching is just that bad. I don't mean nice coach/mean coach, but I mean breaking down how to field a ground ball. Breaking down good throwing mechanics. Girls are not taught a fundamental base to build on, and when you have bad faults you can't progress. In true A ball these kids are taught as 10U players how to approach a ground ball so by the time they are in 14U not only do the look great doing it, but you can progress in training to the next thing. Coaching isn't just about reps. kids will do something improper so long that it's not going to be fixed. Meanwhile the coaches with the talent to fix these issues wouldn't dare go down to 10U to do it:
1. There's no prestige in it.
2. There is a better monetized opportunity to sell these kids private lessons than coach their teams.
Most coaches at the 10-12U level have a knowledge of the game. Few have the ability to communicate that to little kids to where they understand it.
A kid who is a decent athlete and finds A ball at age 8 has a far better chance at surviving in A ball than a kid who finds A ball when they are 13. The reason comp ball swells in 14U is most rec ball programs do not have enough kids to have a senior division (Little League), or have a serious drop at 14U (ASA). The non serious kids find something else to do and the serious kids try to find their way in A ball.
So I don't think the raw talent level is missing, but the developed talent isn't there. Above is a major reason why. I don't believe the development piece is widely available or accessible. Paying $40 per half hour to get lessons prohibits access.