by 3Bsnag » Tue Apr 22, 2008 8:34 pm
The CA teams did have bigger rosters than us out of state folks last year at 12U Nationals, but not by that much. From what I heard, the # of girls increase with each age group. 12U carrying 11-14, 14's carrying 12-15, 16's carrying 13-16, and 18G having as many as 18 girls. I have noticed an increase in rosters in some of the 12 & 14 rosters lately.
Here's my 2 cents. I think at the younger ages a bigger roster is a detriment because other than your core group, the girls aren't getting the game time experience they need at such a developmental age. I'm talking 10-14U. I think money is a factor in SOME of these teams. More girls = more money.
On the flip side, especially starting at 14U, girls are so much more active in other sports and interests that a coach has to cover tournaments for volleyball, basketball, etc. Does that warrant having 6 players on the bench? IMO, no, but I'm not the one juggling travel permits either.
I will leave them nameless, but there's no way a couple of high profile teams here can explain that having 15 or 16 girls on a 12U team is good for anyone, but the coach.
Next thing you know, girls will be starting private batting, throwing, fielding lessons as 6 yr olds so mom and dad can make sure she makes that high profile 12U team in a few years. Ok, a little exagerated, but you get the point.