by gunshy » Thu Apr 28, 2011 9:20 am
Coach, I agree in not running from competition and I never have. BUT, putting up 31 runs on a team speaks volumes about the coach and program, so regardless of the competitive balance my choice would be to play someone else. That score was COMPLETELY within the control of the HSE coach; he could have loaded the bases and just froze his baserunners, he could have stepped off early, or bunted to a player to make outs. Games like this are a race to 12 runs, then make your outs and go home.
Two thoughts on the stats you mention as so important in high school: First, the schools we play usually have a student manager or a parent in the dugout keeping stats and the end product is not worth the paper is is written on. Dubious hits, missed errors and lack of knowledge of the game make many school's stats a joke. I have seen it every week so far, it is not debateable. Every team errs on the side of their players, meaning that averages are usually inflated whenever judgement is involved. Was that a hit or an error? Awww, lets give her a hit.
Second, back to the HSE game and the arguement about asking a hitter to make an out at the plate. If HSE was the home team, they would have batted 4 innings minimum; if EVERY batter scored that did not make an out, they would have had 43 batters come to the plate. That is the absolute minimum. Every batter in the lineup would have batted every inning and at LEAST 4 times, so asking a few kids to bunt to end the game was not going to destroy their averages or keep them from getting recruited. The stat arguement is exaggerated.