Ace wrote:ocdad wrote:I would just like to add my .02, I hope not to get into the current direction of this topic so I would like to address the initial post by Izzy's Dad.
Regarding an actual weight program as part of winter workouts, I think it is absolutely bad for a 12 year old. Especially since it sounds like it is going to be a weekly program - the repeative nature is what would concern me regarding weights. My dd is a small girl & to get stronger she will lift weights from time to time with her cousin that plays football (he is 13). I am not talking about a full weight lifting session, she will do all the cardio stuff with him & will lift light aerobic type weights and do a couple of other thing with different weights, nothing heavy. I see nothing wrong with this, I believe (IMO) it is the repetive nature that puts a strain on the body & leads to many problems for example the repetive nature of pitching, we have seen the threads on this so I will not go any further with it, but just an example. If everyones dd is like mine her book bag weighs more than she would ever try to lift on her own.
As for the impact heavy weights would have on the muscle, in high school we had a body builder work with us, he wanted teach kids how to lift properly. It worked great for us, I got much stronger and a lot more muscle mass than I thought possible, but I played a lot of different sports, noticed my flexibility, range of motion & more important I started to pull more muscles & knees were always swelling up when I went to the heavy lifting. Started playing racketball & cross country & it kept me very limber and I didn't pull any more muscles or knee trouble.
I never thought it a coincidence when the steroids were rampant in MLB that they started to have a ton of injuries: pull hamstring, muscle pulls, etc. I have heard a lot less reported now that they are not as juiced up as they use to be. JMO
I thought the exact opposite. McGuire never stayed healthy until he was on the juice. Look what happened when Barry got off. Look what happened to Gagne after he got off it and so on and so on. Steroids help you heal and recover more quickly.
You are right about the recovery time, what I was talking about were the completely torn muscles, blown out ACL's, shoulders etc. Muscles too tight & rigid, so instead of having slight tears you had complete blow outs & all the players you reference led to everyone following, but the key thing you miss is the positions they played. Gagne closer - 1 inning, McGuire DH or 1st. The only one that had to move was Bonds & when he started to use he wasn't know for his defense anymore it was all about the HR's he went from Gold Glove to defensive liability out there. If you remember during that time everyone was looking at the workout practices of the players that were getting hurt - they all looked like damn action figures & the talk started to turn to less heavy weight lifting.


























